Computing Circumscription Revisited: A Reduction Algorithm

  • Authors:

  • Patrick Doherty;Witold Łukaszewicz;Andrzej Szałas

  • Affiliations:

  • Department of Computer and Information Science, Linköping University, S-581 83 Linköping, Sweden. e-mail: patdo@ida.liu.se;Institute of Informatics, Warsaw University, 02-097 Warsaw, Banacha 2, Poland. e-mail: witlu/szalas@mimuw.edu.pl;Institute of Informatics, Warsaw University, 02-097 Warsaw, Banacha 2, Poland. e-mail: witlu/szalas@mimuw.edu.pl

  • Venue:
  • Journal of Automated Reasoning
  • Year:
  • 1997

Quantified Score

Hi-index 0.00

Visualization

Abstract

In recent years, a great deal of attention has been devoted to logics of common-sense reasoning. Among the candidates proposed, circumscription has been perceived as an elegant mathematical technique for modeling nonmonotonic reasoning, but difficult to apply in practice. The major reason for this is the second-order nature of circumscription axioms and the difficulty in finding proper substitutions of predicate expressions for predicate variables. One solution to this problem is to compile, where possible, second-order formulas into equivalent first-order formulas. Although some progress has been made using this approach, the results are not as strong as one might desire and they are isolated in nature. In this article, we provide a general method that can be used in an algorithmic manner to reduce certain circumscription axioms to first-order formulas. The algorithm takes as input an arbitrary second-order formula and either returns as output an equivalent first-order formula, or terminates with failure. The class of second-order formulas, and analogously the class of circumscriptive theories that can be reduced, provably subsumes those covered by existing results. We demonstrate the generality of the algorithm using circumscriptive theories with mixed quantifiers (some involving Skolemization), variable constants, nonseparated formulas, and formulas with n-ary predicate variables. In addition, we analyze the strength of the algorithm, compare it with existing approaches, and provide formal subsumption results.