A Comparison of Two Proof Critics: Power vs. Robustness

  • Authors:
  • Louise A. Dennis;Alan Bundy

  • Affiliations:
  • -;-

  • Venue:
  • TPHOLs '02 Proceedings of the 15th International Conference on Theorem Proving in Higher Order Logics
  • Year:
  • 2002

Quantified Score

Hi-index 0.00

Visualization

Abstract

Proof critics are a technology from the proof planning paradigm. They examine failed proof attempts in order to extract information which can be used to generate a patch which will allow the proof to go through.We consider the proof of the "whisky problem", a challenge problem from the domain of temporal logic. The proof requires a generalisation of the original conjecture and we examine two proof critics which can be used to create this generalisation. Using these critics we believe we have produced the first automatic proofs of this challenge problem.We use this example to motivate a comparison of the two critics and propose that there is a place for specialist critics as well as powerful general critics. In particular we advocate the development of critics that do not use meta-variables.