Using Experiments to Build a Body of Knowledge

• Authors: Victor R. Basili;Forrest Shull;Filippo Lanubile
• Venue: PSI '99 Proceedings of the Third International Andrei Ershov Memorial Conference on Perspectives of System Informatics
• Year: 1999

Experimentation in software engineering is important but diffcult. One reason it is so diffcult is that there are a large number of context variables, and so creating a cohesive understanding of experimental results requires a mechanism for motivating studies and integrating results. This paper argues for the necessity of a framework for organizing sets of related studies. With such a framework, experiments can be viewed as part of common families of studies, rather than being isolated events. Common families of studies can contribute to important and relevant hypotheses that may not be suggested by individual experiments. A framework also facilitates building knowledge in an incremental manner through the replication of experiments within families of studies. Building knowledge in this way requires a community of researchers that can replicate studies, vary context variables, and build abstract models that represent the common observations about the discipline. This paper also presents guidelines for lab packages, meant to encourage and support replications, that encapsulate materials, methods, and experiences concerning software engineering experiments.