Cognitive Differences Between Procedural Programming and Object Oriented Programming

Authors:
Garry White;Marcos Sivitanides
Affiliations:
Computer Information Systems, Texas State University at San Marcos, San Marcos 78666;Computer Information Systems, Texas State University at San Marcos, San Marcos 78666
Venue:
Information Technology and Management
Year:
2005

Citing 14
Cited 0

A model curriculum for a liberal arts degree in computer science

Communications of the ACM - The MIT Press scientific computation series
Logic as a formal method

The Computer Journal - Special issue on formal methods: part 1
Strategic directions in object-oriented programming

ACM Computing Surveys (CSUR) - Special ACM 50th-anniversary issue: strategic directions in computing research
Component architectures, the Web and open middleware all figured prominently last year as enterprise app vendors geared up for the future

Software Magazine
An introduction to Object COBOL

An introduction to Object COBOL
The effects of learning a programming language on logical thinking skills

The effects of learning a programming language on logical thinking skills
User cognitive representations: the case for an object oriented model

Journal of Systems and Software
Surveying object technology usage and benefits: a test of conventional wisdom

Information and Management
Aspect-oriented programming: Introduction

Communications of the ACM
Object-Oriented Development in COBOL

Object-Oriented Development in COBOL
A predictor for success in an introductory programming class based upon abstract reasoning development

SIGCSE '83 Proceedings of the fourteenth SIGCSE technical symposium on Computer science education
Predicting success in the undergraduate introductory computer science course using the theory of planned behavior

Predicting success in the undergraduate introductory computer science course using the theory of planned behavior
Exploring the difficulties of learning object-oriented techniques

Journal of Management Information Systems - Special section: Strategic and competitive information systems
Cognitive activities and levels of abstraction in procedural and object-oriented design

Human-Computer Interaction

Quantified Score

Hi-index	0.00

Visualization

Abstract

Software development is moving from procedural programming towards object-oriented programming (OOP). Past studies in cognitive aspects of programming have focused primarily on procedural programming languages. Object-oriented programming is a new paradigm for computing. Industry is finding that programmers are having difficulty shifting to this new programming paradigm.Findings in prior research revealed that procedural programming requires Piaget's formal operation cognitive level. New from this research is that OOP also requires Piaget's formal operation cognitive level. Also new is that OOP appears to be unrelated to hemispheric cognitive style. OOP appears to be hemispheric style friendly, while procedural programming is preferential to left hemispheric cognitive style.The conclusion is that cognitive requirements are not the cause for the difficulty in shifting from procedural to OOP. An alternative possibility to the difficulty is proactive interference of learning procedural programming prior to learning object oriented programming.