The Value of Partial Resource Pooling: Should a Service Network Be Integrated or Product-Focused?

Authors:
Barış Ata;Jan A. Van Mieghem
Affiliations:
Kellogg School of Management, Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois 60208;Kellogg School of Management, Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois 60208
Venue:
Management Science
Year:
2009

Citing 12
Cited 1

Explicit Solutions for Variational Problems in the Quadrant

Queueing Systems: Theory and Applications
Heavy traffic approximations of large deviations of feedforward queueing networks

Queueing Systems: Theory and Applications
Large deviations of the steady-state distribution of reflected processes with applications to queueing systems

Queueing Systems: Theory and Applications
Heavy traffic resource pooling in parallel-server systems

Queueing Systems: Theory and Applications
Managing Business Process Flows

Managing Business Process Flows
Newsvendor Networks: Inventory Management and Capacity Investment with Discretionary Activities

Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
Price and Service Discrimination in Queuing Systems: Incentive Compatibility of Gcµ Scheduling

Management Science
Commissioned Paper: Telephone Call Centers: Tutorial, Review, and Research Prospects

Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
Making simulation relevant in business: to pool or not to pool? "the benefits of combining queuing and simulation"

Proceedings of the 34th conference on Winter simulation: exploring new frontiers
Continuum approximation techniques for the design of integrated package distribution systems

Networks
Multimarket Facility Network Design with Offshoring Applications

Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
Dynamic Control of N-Systems with Many Servers: Asymptotic Optimality of a Static Priority Policy in Heavy Traffic

Operations Research

Efficiency evaluation for pooling resources in health care

OR Spectrum

Quantified Score

Hi-index	0.01

Visualization

Abstract

We investigate how dynamic resource substitution in service systems impacts capacity requirements and responsiveness. Inspired by the contrasting network strategies of FedEx and United Parcel Service (UPS), we study when two service classes (e.g., express or regular) should be served by dedicated resources (e.g., air or ground) or by an integrated network (e.g., air also serves regular). Using call center terminology, the question is whether to operate two independent queues or one N-network. We present analytic expressions for the delay distributions and the value of network integration through partial resource pooling. These show how the value of network integration depends on service quality (speed and reliability of service) and demand characteristics (volume averages and covariance matrix). Our results suggest that network integration is of little value and operating dedicated networks is a fine strategy if the firm primarily serves express requests with high reliability and if the correlation with regular requests is not strongly negative. In contrast, network integration offers significant gains for firms serving primarily regular requests, almost independent of correlation. Our analysis provides the intuition behind these findings in terms of three main drivers of integration value: arrival pooling, the substitution effect, and the correlation effect.