Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology
Journal of Information Science
Compromised need and the label effect: An examination of claims and evidence
Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology
Interactive Information Retrieval in Digital Environments
Interactive Information Retrieval in Digital Environments
| Hi-index | 0.00 |
This study uses bibliometric analysis and citation context analysis to identify the influence of the main concepts embedded in Taylor's 1968 classic article entitled Question-Negotiation and Information-Seeking in Libraries. This study analyses articles published between 1969 and 2010 which cite Taylor's article. The results show that Taylor's article on a question-negotiation model is increasingly visible and its influence is not limited to the discipline of library and information science. Of the 14 cited concepts identified, the concept of ''four levels of information needs'' was cited most (31.7%), followed by ''question negotiation'' (20.5%) and ''other concepts relating to information needs'' (17.9%). The results indicate an increasing trend in the citations of ''four levels of information needs'' and this concept also received the most attention from information retrieval research. A decreasing trend was evident for the concept of ''question negotiation'' and this concept was frequently cited by reference service researchers. In addition, among the 10 citation functions, ''related literature'' was dominant (30.8%). Both ''evidence'' and ''views'' were in second place with the same percentage (18.7%), followed by ''terms'' (9.2%) and ''background information'' (7.2%). A decreasing trend was identified in the top three citation functions, whereas an increasing trend was observed in the ''term'' and ''background information'' functions.