The apprentice challenge

• Authors: J. Strother Moore;George Porter
• Venue: ACM Transactions on Programming Languages and Systems (TOPLAS)
• Year: 2002

We describe a mechanically checked proof of a property of a small system of Java programs involving an unbounded number of threads and synchronization, via monitors. We adopt the output of the javac compiler as the semantics and verify the system at the bytecode level under an operational semantics for the JVM. We assume a sequentially consistent memory model and atomicity at the bytecode level. Our operational semantics is expressed in ACL2, a Lisp-based logic of recursive functions. Our proofs are checked with the ACL2 theorem prover. The proof involves reasoning about arithmetic; infinite loops; the creation and modification of instance objects in the heap, including threads; the inheritance of fields from superclasses; pointer chasing and smashing; the invocation of instance methods (and the concomitant dynamic method resolution); use of the start method on thread objects; the use of monitors to attain synchronization between threads; and consideration of all possible interleavings (at the bytecode level) over an unbounded number of threads. Readers familiar with monitor-based proofs of mutual exclusion will recognize our proof as fairly classical. The novelty here comes from (i) the complexity of the individual operations on the abstract machine; (ii) the dependencies between Java threads, heap objects, and synchronization; (iii) the bytecode-level interleaving; (iv) the unbounded number of threads; (v) the presence in the heap of incompletely initialized threads and other objects; and (vi) the proof engineering permitting automatic mechanical verification of code-level theorems. We discuss these issues. The problem posed here is also put forth as a benchmark against which to measure other approaches to formally proving properties of multithreaded Java programs.