Implementing risk-limiting post-election audits in California

  • Authors:
  • Joseph Lorenzo Hall;Luke W. Miratrix;Philip B. Stark;Melvin Briones;Elaine Ginnold;Freddie Oakley;Martin Peaden;Gail Pellerin;Tom Stanionis;Tricia Webber

  • Affiliations:
  • School of Information, University of California, Berkeley and Center for Information Technology Policy, Princeton University;Department of Statistics, University of California, Berkeley;Department of Statistics, University of California, Berkeley;Registrar of Voters, Marin County, California;Registrar of Voters, Marin County, California;Recorder, Yolo County, California;Santa Cruz County, County Clerk, California;Santa Cruz County, County Clerk, California;Recorder, Yolo County, California;Santa Cruz County, County Clerk, California

  • Venue:
  • EVT/WOTE'09 Proceedings of the 2009 conference on Electronic voting technology/workshop on trustworthy elections
  • Year:
  • 2009

Quantified Score

Hi-index 0.00

Visualization

Abstract

Risk-limiting postelection audits limit the chance of certifying an electoral outcome if the outcome is not what a full hand count would show. Building on previous work [18, 17, 20, 21, 11], we report pilot risk-limiting audits in four elections during 2008 in three California counties: one during the February 2008 Primary Election in Marin County and three during the November 2008 General Elections in Marin, Santa Cruz and Yolo Counties. We explain what makes an audit risk-limiting and how existing and proposed laws fall short. We discuss the differences among our four pilot audits. We identify challenges to practical, efficient risk-limiting audits and conclude that current approaches are too complex to be used routinely on a large scale. One important logistical bottleneck is the difficulty of exporting data from commercial election management systems in a format amenable to audit calculations. Finally, we propose a barebones risk-limiting audit that is less efficient than these pilot audits, but avoids many practical problems.