Synthesizing User Centered and Designer Centered IS Development Approaches Using General Systems Theory

Authors:
Edward J. Garrity
Affiliations:
Management Computer Information Systems Department, Richard J. Wehle School of Business, Canisius College, Buffalo, NY 14208, USA. Garrity@canisius.edu
Venue:
Information Systems Frontiers
Year:
2001

Citing 24
Cited 1

Propaedeutics of decision-making: supporting managerial learning and innovation

Decision Support Systems
Implementation and structural variables

Information and Management
Artificial intelligence (2nd ed.)

Artificial intelligence (2nd ed.)
Rethinking the concept of user involvement

MIS Quarterly
A problem-solving perspective on systems development

Journal of Management Information Systems
A retrospective look at PD projects

Communications of the ACM - Special issue Participatory Design
PD and joint application design: a transatlantic comparison

Communications of the ACM - Special issue Participatory Design
From programming environments to environments for designing

Communications of the ACM
Information systems development and data modeling: conceptual and philosophical foundations

Information systems development and data modeling: conceptual and philosophical foundations
Transforming work: collaboration, learning, and design

Communications of the ACM
Making representations work

Communications of the ACM
Making work visible

Communications of the ACM
Participatory design

Communications of the ACM - Special issue Participatory Design
Communication richness in electronic mail: critical social theory and the contextuality of meaning

MIS Quarterly
Introduction to information systems success measurement

Information systems success measurement
Dimensions of information systems success

Information systems success measurement
Five small secrets to systems success

Information systems success measurement
Building change-readiness capabilities in the IS organization: insights from the Bell Atlantic experience

MIS Quarterly
Beyond the productivity paradox

Communications of the ACM
Software cultures

Communications of the ACM
Enterprise resource planning: making ERP a success

Communications of the ACM
The reality of user-centered design

Journal of End User Computing - Special issue on human-centered research and practice
Human-Computer Interaction

Human-Computer Interaction
Human Problem Solving

Human Problem Solving

Information systems innovation for environmental sustainability

MIS Quarterly

Quantified Score

Hi-index	0.00

Visualization

Abstract

This paper uses general systems theory to provide an expanded view of information systems in organizations. Three general viewpoints and corresponding approaches to information systems development are identified. The designer centered or American approach to information systems development is based on a “functionalist” perspective of information systems and a problem solving orientation. The user centered or European approach to information systems development takes an expanded view of information systems that specifically considers humans and recognizes their aspirations and goals and uses a democratic, participative approach to develop systems in an effort to produce an improved workplace and a better quality of worklife for users. A third viewpoint on information systems development, business process centering, is identified that further expands the components of the system to include the set of integrated tasks that provide value to the customer. We define a new development approach that combines the strengths of these approaches based on general systems theory, business process centering, and a measurement and control system.